New York Giants News and Rumors: Carl Banks Picks Jaxson Dart, JJ McCarthy PFF Throw Rate, Nikko Reed Returns
Published Nov 18, 2026, 10:45 PM ET | By Vincent Rapisardi

Wednesday's Giants news ran through the quarterback room. Giants great Carl Banks picked Jaxson Dart over JJ McCarthy for 2027, a day when PFF ranked McCarthy's 8.8% big-time throw rate first among 37 qualifying quarterbacks.
Here is every story we published on Nov. 18, 2026.
Carl Banks has made his call on the Giants' 2027 quarterback job.
Asked on Brandon Tierney's Unleashed show who starts in training camp, the former Giants linebacker said, "Jaxson Dart. ... He's better. Trust me when I tell you," as Big Blue Film Room shared on X.
He went further. "By the time they get to training camp, McCarthy will be somebody else's quarterback and the Giants would have gotten a first round draft choice for him," Banks said.
That would be a steep return. The Giants landed McCarthy from Minnesota on Sept. 28 for a 2027 fifth-round pick, Pro Football Network reported.
Banks still credited McCarthy, saying "his footwork is so much better" since the trade. His forecast is an opinion, and John Harbaugh has not set a 2027 quarterback order.
Dart's nine rushing touchdowns as a rookie set the Giants' single-season record for a quarterback, per his Giants.com bio. Vincent Rapisardi sides with Banks: "JD6 is the future."
McCarthy's arm now has a league-leading number behind it. His 8.8% big-time throw rate is the highest among 37 quarterbacks with at least 80 dropbacks, according to PFF's Week 10 "32 teams, 32 observations" column by Mark Chichester.
The same column credits him with 10 big-time throws and an 80.4 overall grade, ninth among 39 quarterbacks with at least 140 offensive snaps.
PFF defines a big-time throw as a pass with excellent ball location and timing, generally thrown farther downfield or into a tighter window, per the Vikings' site.
The sample is small. McCarthy has completed 66 of 104 passes for 915 yards, two touchdowns and two interceptions in five appearances, per Giants.com. Last season, only 51.7% of his throws were charted as accurate, 42nd of 43 passers, PFF noted.
Vincent Rapisardi saw the velocity early. After Week 7, he wrote that he had never seen a quarterback throw as hard.
McCarthy has added touch to the fastball, and SNY's Connor Hughes traced the change to the offseason.
In an SNY report from outside MetLife Stadium, Hughes said McCarthy spent time on layered throws with his quarterback coach, John Beck. "He didn't have to just throw fastball after fastball," Hughes said, as Big Blue Film Room shared on X.
McCarthy explained Wednesday why touch came late. Growing up in Chicago, "there's a lot of times where you'd cut it through that wind," he said, per the Giants' transcript. He spent this offseason "really just hammering it home over in Orange County" with Beck, he said.
The efficiency has followed. McCarthy is averaging 8.8 yards per attempt with the Giants, up from 6.7 in 10 starts for Minnesota in 2025, per Giants.com. The caveat is volume: 104 attempts in New York, compared with 243 last season.
Harbaugh said Wednesday that McCarthy has "been playing winning football." The 7-2 Jaguars visit Sunday at 4:25 p.m. ET, per Giants.com.
Cornerback Nikko Reed is back with the Giants, this time on the practice squad.
"The Giants are re-signing CB Nikko Reed to the practice squad, per source," The Athletic's Dan Duggan wrote on X. Reed "takes the place of RB Eric Gray, who was cut from the practice squad yesterday," Duggan added.
The Giants had waived Reed on Monday along with receiver Charlie Jones, per Giants.com, clearing room for Tavierre Thomas and Xavier Gipson.
Reed, 23, went undrafted out of Oregon in 2025, and New York signed him off the Chargers' practice squad on Sept. 18, Giants.com said. He appeared in three games for the Giants and played 33 special teams snaps, the team said. ESPN credits him with one tackle.
Big Blue View's Ed Valentine also reported the move.
Ar'Darius Washington's 89.9 grade in the 24-21 loss to the Commanders led all 82 qualifying safeties in Week 10, according to PFF.
He played 54 snaps and allowed three catches on six targets for 11 yards, with an interception and a pass breakup, per PFF.
The interception came on fourth-and-2 at the Washington 45 with 2:15 left, Giants.com reported. Quan Martin was the next-best safety in the game at 64.8, per PFF's game grades.
Washington came to New York on a one-year deal after five seasons with Harbaugh in Baltimore, the Giants announced in March. He was the third former Raven to agree with the Giants that week, after Isaiah Likely and Jordan Stout, BaltimoreRavens.com reported.
The caveat is the sample: he has started four of his eight games this season, per Giants.com. Every grade is tracked on our Giants PFF grades page. Vincent Rapisardi's view of the Baltimore pipeline this week: "Thank you @Ravens for John Harbaugh."
Amani Toomer had blunt advice for Malik Nabers in a conversation with Phil and Matt Simms posted Wednesday by Bleav.
"If you have rabbit ears in this city, not a good thing. You don't need to address every single situation," Toomer said, as Big Blue Film Room shared on X.
The backdrop is Nabers' since-deleted Instagram story pushing back on Fox's Greg Olsen and Joe Davis after the Nov. 8 win in Philadelphia, ProFootballTalk reported.
Toomer also revisited the final drive against Washington, when McCarthy's deep pass for Nabers was intercepted with 25 seconds left, Giants.com reported. "You got to grab and bite and scratch and claw. That thing is not getting intercepted," Toomer said.
Nabers said the day after the game that he "didn't really see" the defender, according to the Giants' transcript.
Toomer still called him "a phenomenal player." Nabers has 58 catches for 692 yards through nine games. Vincent Rapisardi's message last week was similar: "Time to grow up Malik."
Wink Martindale took aim at the Giants' previous regime on Pat Leonard's Talkin' Ball podcast. "Skattebo for example, he's a great example of why the old Giants lost," the former defensive coordinator said, as Big Blue Film Room shared on X.
"The old regime was more interested in the buzz, the headlines," Martindale added, per the same post. "How about pick up a blitz?" he asked.
Martindale resigned as Giants defensive coordinator in January 2024, and the Giants fired Brian Daboll in November 2025 after a 2-8 start. He referred to "the old regime" rather than naming Daboll.
Skattebo lost a fumble at Washington in Week 5 and had no carries in Week 6, per his Giants.com game log. He then ran 17 times for 124 yards at Houston and scored twice against the Commanders.
He has 496 rushing yards and four touchdowns on 116 carries, but also four fumbles, one lost, per Giants.com.
Vincent Rapisardi has backed the running back since October: "He's the best back they have."
Want more Giants coverage? Catch up on all of our latest articles here on the site, and follow @BigBlueFilmRoom on X for every Giants update as it breaks.
About Big Blue Film Room: Big Blue Film Room is an independent New York Giants news site delivering daily news, injury updates and game recaps. We credit and link to the original reporting behind every story, and we correct errors promptly under our Editorial Standards. Learn more about who we are and how we report on our About page.
Get Big Blue Film Room Daily
Every Giants story from yesterday in one free email at 7 AM ET.








Comments