Jaxson Dart Is Better Than JJ McCarthy, Giants Great Carl Banks Says
Published Nov 18, 2026, 4:36 PM ET | By Vincent Rapisardi
Key points
Carl Banks said Jaxson Dart would be the Giants' starter at 2027 training camp, even if JJ McCarthy keeps playing well.
Banks predicted McCarthy will be "somebody else's quarterback" and could bring back a first-round pick.
Banks made his case Wednesday on Brandon Tierney's Unleashed show.
Jaxson Dart is still the Giants' quarterback of the future in Carl Banks' eyes. The former Giants linebacker said in an interview posted Wednesday that Dart would be QB1 next season, even if JJ McCarthy keeps playing well.
Banks made the call on Brandon Tierney's Unleashed show. Asked who starts in camp, he said, "Jaxson Dart. ... He's better. Trust me when I tell you," as shared by Big Blue Film Room on X.
Banks won Super Bowls XXI and XXV with the Giants and has been a team radio analyst since 2007, per Giants.com. On Tuesday, Giants Wire highlighted Phil Simms telling fans they're "lucky as hell" to have McCarthy.
Why Carl Banks Says Jaxson Dart Wins the Job
Tierney pushed back, calling football "the ultimate meritocracy," and asked what Dart does better. "Things that they require in that offense. He's better at it," Banks said.
Banks pointed to the summer. "If you spent any time in their training camps, you'd see why I say that," he said. Told McCarthy wasn't in that camp, Banks said, "I think Dart comes out on top."
He still praised McCarthy, saying "his footwork is so much better" since the trade.
Carl Banks Sees a First-Round Price for JJ McCarthy
Banks went further than the depth chart. "By the time they get to training camp, McCarthy will be somebody else's quarterback and the Giants would have gotten a first round draft choice for him," he said.
He pointed to "such a deficit at the quarterback position right now." A developed, winning McCarthy is "easily a first round draft choice and then maybe another pick," Banks said.
For context, the Giants got McCarthy from Minnesota on Sept. 28 for a 2027 fifth-round pick, Pro Football Network reported. We covered Vic Fangio calling that trade a steal.
By the Numbers: Jaxson Dart vs. JJ McCarthy
Stat | Dart (2025) | McCarthy (2026, Giants) |
Games (starts) | 14 (12) | 5 (3) |
Completion rate | 63.7% | 63.5% |
Passing yards | 2,272 | 915 |
TD-INT | 15-5 | 2-2 |
Rushing TDs | 9 | 0 |
Source: Giants.com player pages for Jaxson Dart and JJ McCarthy.
The samples are not equal: a full rookie season against five Giants appearances. McCarthy has averaged 8.8 yards per attempt in New York, per Giants.com.
Dart's nine rushing touchdowns set the Giants' single-season record for a quarterback, per his bio. We compared all three quarterbacks in Dart vs. Winston vs. McCarthy by the Numbers.
What Comes Next for Jaxson Dart and the Giants
Dart suffered a knee injury in the first half of the Week 2 loss to the Rams that required surgery, Giants Wire reported. John Harbaugh has not set a 2027 quarterback order, per Pro Football Network.
Banks' trade forecast is his opinion, not a report of talks. The 5-3-1 Giants host the 7-2 Jaguars on Sunday at 4:25 p.m. ET. McCarthy enters with PFF's top big-time throw rate among qualifiers.
Our Take: Carl Banks Is Right About Jaxson Dart
I'm with Banks on the big question. I wrote last month that "Jaxson Dart is still the longterm guy." After the Commanders loss, I posted, "JD6 is the future."
In September, I said Dart is "still the guy in 2027." This morning, I wrote that a full season with Malik Nabers, Isaiah Likely and Cam Skattebo around him could be dangerous.
None of that is a knock on McCarthy. In that Nov. 13 post, I said the loss wasn't on him and that he played well. In October, I said he is "the now."
On the deal itself, I noted it went from "why would the Giants do something so stupid" to "the Giants fleeced Minnesota" within a month. He has 915 yards in five Giants games.
Want more Giants coverage? Catch up on all of our latest articles here on the site, and follow @BigBlueFilmRoom on X for every Giants update as it breaks.
About Big Blue Film Room: Big Blue Film Room is an independent New York Giants news site delivering daily news, injury updates and game recaps. We credit and link to the original reporting behind every story, and we correct errors promptly under our Editorial Standards. Learn more about who we are and how we report on our About page.
Get Big Blue Film Room Daily
Every Giants story from yesterday in one free email at 7 AM ET.











Comments