top of page

Jonathan Taylor Trade: Colts Would 'Strongly Consider' Giants' Offer

7 days ago
4 min read

Published Nov 9, 2026, 8:16 PM ET | By Vincent Rapisardi


Key points

  • Jordan Schultz says two NFL executives believe the Colts would strongly consider the Giants' original Jonathan Taylor offer if it returned.

  • ESPN's Adam Schefter said the Giants offered a second-round pick and a player, without knowing who the player was.

  • The trade deadline is Tuesday at 4 p.m. ET; no new Giants offer has been reported.


Jonathan Taylor and the Giants may not be finished after all. NFL insider Jordan Schultz said Monday that two league executives believe the Colts would "strongly consider" New York's original offer if it came back.


The Colts would "strongly consider" accepting the Giants' original offer "if the deal was put back on the table," Big Blue Film Room posted on X. Schultz made the comments with Ryan Clark on The Pivot, in a video he posted Monday evening.


That is the offer New York pulled on Sunday. Coach John Harbaugh confirmed the Giants withdrew it, per ESPN. That came hours after we covered the Giants cooling on Taylor over the Colts' asking price.



What Schultz Heard About the Jonathan Taylor Offer


Schultz said the Giants previously offered Indianapolis a second-round pick "plus additional comp." He added there is a chance that offer comes back this week, following New York's 19-11 win over the Eagles.


Indianapolis is not desperate. Schultz was told the Colts "don't want to force a trade," because Taylor's contract lets them revisit a deal in the offseason. "We want to make sure we get max value," he said of their view.


The Giants' Original Offer, as Reported


ESPN's Adam Schefter said Monday on The Pat McAfee Show that the Giants offered "a second-round pick and a player," according to Heavy. He added, "I don't know who the player was."


Underdog relayed Schefter's report as a second-round pick, a fifth-round pick and a player. Fox Sports' Jay Glazer reported the second and fifth on Sunday, Pro Football Rumors noted.


The Athletic's Dan Duggan noted the fifth must be a 2028 pick, since the Giants lack a 2027 fifth, per that report. No report has named the player.



By the Numbers: Jonathan Taylor in 2025 vs. 2026


Season

Carries / Yards / TD

Yards per carry

2025 (17 games)

323 / 1,585 / 18

4.9

2026 (9 games)

161 / 656 / 8

4.1


Source: ESPN's Jonathan Taylor stats page, as of Nov. 9, 2026.


His efficiency is down, but he is no rental. Taylor is under club control through 2028, Pro Football Rumors reported.


Why the Giants' Backfield Keeps Jonathan Taylor in Play


The need has not changed. Cam Skattebo missed Sunday's game with a hamstring injury, and Tyrone Tracy Jr. is on injured reserve, ESPN reported.



Harbaugh left the door open. "Things change from day to day," he said. He also drew a line, per ESPN: "I'm not just going to go for a short-term fix at exorbitant cost."


What Comes Next Before Tuesday's Trade Deadline


The deadline is Tuesday at 4 p.m. ET, Schultz noted. The 5-2-1 Giants then host the Commanders on Thursday night, so any move would land in a short week.


Schultz did not report that the Giants plan to bring the offer back, and no new offer had been reported as of Monday night. On Nov. 5, ESPN's Jordan Raanan reported the Giants had made an offer while the Colts showed no rush.


Our Take: Make the Jonathan Taylor Deal Happen


My reaction to Schultz's report was three words: Make it happen.


I felt that way before this report. When Schefter's details on the original offer came out Monday afternoon, I asked, How does this not get a deal done?


Jonathan Taylor ran for 1,585 yards and 18 touchdowns last season, and he is signed through 2028. That is a proven player.



I even asked my followers whether they would trade a 2027 second, a 2028 fifth and Cam Skattebo for Taylor. That was my own hypothetical, not a report on the actual offer.


If the Colts would strongly consider the original package, the Giants should put it back on the table before 4 p.m. Tuesday.


Want more Giants coverage? Catch up on all of our latest articles here on the site, and follow @BigBlueFilmRoom on X for every Giants update as it breaks.


About Big Blue Film Room: Big Blue Film Room is an independent New York Giants news site delivering daily news, injury updates and game recaps. We credit and link to the original reporting behind every story, and we correct errors promptly under our Editorial Standards. Learn more about who we are and how we report on our About page.


Get Big Blue Film Room Daily

Every Giants story from yesterday in one free email at 7 AM ET.

Comments


Top Stories

bottom of page