Giants' John Harbaugh Was 'Coaching Scared,' Stephen A. Smith Says
Published Nov 14, 2026, 2:28 PM ET | By Vincent Rapisardi
Key points
ESPN's Stephen A. Smith said John Harbaugh's Giants "were coaching scared" in Thursday's 24-21 loss to Washington.
New York ran on all six snaps after Washington's two fourth-quarter interceptions and punted both times, per ESPN.
The Giants, 5-3-1, still lead the NFC East by 1.5 games over Dallas.
John Harbaugh is taking heat from ESPN's Stephen A. Smith after the Giants' 24-21 loss to the Commanders. On Friday's First Take, Smith said the Giants "were coaching scared" in the fourth quarter.
"They were coaching scared. I mean, John Harbaugh should be ashamed of himself," Smith said, as Big Blue Film Room shared on X. It was New York's first division loss, per Giants.com.
The Giants, 5-3-1, still sit first in the NFC East, 1.5 games ahead of 4-5 Dallas, according to ESPN's standings. We covered Harbaugh's own explanation, including his "may be more aggressive" comment, in our breakdown of his fourth-down calls.
What Stephen A. Smith Said About John Harbaugh
Smith pointed to the Giants' last three possessions, which gained 31 net yards. ESPN's drive chart matches that total: 5, 5 and 21 yards.
He called the approach "a bit outdated" and said it was a problem that "existed in Baltimore," per Pro Football Network. Smith also credited Harbaugh as a Super Bowl champion who knows how to lead.
Smith raised Harbaugh's history of blown fourth-quarter leads. NFL Research had his Ravens at 46 through 2025, tied for second-most since 2008, PFN reported. PFN said Thursday made it 47, which DraftKings called the most by any coach in that span.
One detail was off. The Jameis Winston snap Smith described as "third and one" came on fourth-and-1, PFN noted. That fourth down ended in a delay-of-game penalty and a punt, per ESPN's play-by-play.
By the Numbers: John Harbaugh's Giants After the Late Interceptions
Possession | Plays | Result |
After Holland INT, 5:27 left | 3 runs, 5 yards | Punt |
After Washington INT, 2:15 left | 3 runs, 5 yards | Punt |
After Diggs TD, 0:57 left | 4 passes, 21 yards | Interception |
Source: ESPN play-by-play and ESPN drive chart.
The Numbers Behind the John Harbaugh Criticism
ESPN's win probability model gave the Giants a 93.2% chance after Ar'Darius Washington's interception with 2:19 left, per ESPN's game page. Smith cited the same figure on First Take.
The Giants then ran three times and punted from the Washington 41. Washington needed three plays and 49 seconds to go 71 yards for the winning score, per ESPN.
The caveat: New York outgained Washington 399 yards to 340, per ESPN's box score. Third down hurt more: the Giants went 4-for-12, while Washington went 7-for-14. Harbaugh also cited the wind in passing on long field goals, as we detailed Friday.
What Comes Next for John Harbaugh and the Giants
The Giants host the AFC South-leading Jaguars in Week 11, in a game flexed to 4:25 p.m., per Giants.com.
Smith predicted the Giants would lose "at least four more games" over the next six weeks, on First Take. That is his opinion, not a report. Harbaugh said in October that the Giants can win this division.
Our Take: John Harbaugh Still Has the Giants in First Place
That one stings, as I posted when Thursday's game ended. The numbers from those two late drives are stark: six runs, 10 yards and two punts, per ESPN.
Still, a day after the loss I said I am still thankful for John Harbaugh. One loss did not change that.
In October, I wrote that it is insane how much Harbaugh has changed the direction of the Giants. I also said this is the Giants' division, thanks to John Harbaugh. At 5-3-1 and 1.5 games up, the standings still read that way.
Smith's 47 blown leads, per PFN, span every season since 2008. Thursday was one game. Against Jacksonville, I will watch what the Giants call the next time they get the ball back late with a lead.
Want more Giants coverage? Catch up on all of our latest articles here on the site, and follow @BigBlueFilmRoom on X for every Giants update as it breaks.
About Big Blue Film Room: Big Blue Film Room is an independent New York Giants news site delivering daily news, injury updates and game recaps. We credit and link to the original reporting behind every story, and we correct errors promptly under our Editorial Standards. Learn more about who we are and how we report on our About page.
Get Big Blue Film Room Daily
Every Giants story from yesterday in one free email at 7 AM ET.











Comments