top of page

Giants Trade Deadline: No 'Impact Player,' No Deal, Duggan Says

4 days ago
3 min read

Published Nov 12, 2026, 12:10 PM ET | By Vincent Rapisardi


Key points

  • The Athletic's Dan Duggan reported the Giants would not trade draft picks unless the return was an impact player.

  • He wrote that the team trusts its defensive tackle depth, with rookie Bobby Jamison-Travis playing well against the run.

  • The first-place Giants host the Commanders on Thursday night at MetLife Stadium.


The Giants trade deadline plan came down to one rule, per The Athletic's Dan Duggan. No draft picks would be spent unless the return was an impact player. Tuesday's deadline passed without a move.


Duggan's report was shared by Big Blue Film Room on X on Thursday morning. He added that the Giants have "confidence" in their defensive line, especially rookie Bobby Jamison-Travis.




Why the Giants Trade Deadline Price Was Too High


Duggan pointed to the cost of impact players. Jacksonville sent first- and second-round picks to Philadelphia for defensive tackle Jordan Davis, who has never made a Pro Bowl or an All-Pro team.


The Giants' most realistic star target was Jonathan Taylor. Harbaugh confirmed an offer of a 2027 second-round pick and a 2028 fifth-round pick, Duggan wrote. Indianapolis needed to be blown away and was not.


New York also lacked middle-round picks. Its fourth-rounder went to trade up for Malachi Fields in the draft, and its fifth went to Minnesota for JJ McCarthy in September.


By the Numbers: Giants Trade Deadline Prices


Player (pos.)

Move

Price

Jordan Davis (DT)

Eagles to Jaguars

1st + 2nd

Jessie Bates (S)

Falcons to Jaguars

2nd + 5th

Davon Godchaux (DT)

Saints to Jaguars

6th

Jonathan Taylor (RB)

Giants offer, not accepted

2027 2nd + 2028 5th



Godchaux is the kind of deal the Giants skipped. Duggan wrote they had no interest in spending a Day 3 pick on a player who does not move the needle.



Bobby Jamison-Travis and the Giants Defensive Line


Jamison-Travis is a big reason the Giants felt comfortable up front. Duggan wrote that the rookie has played well against the run over the past three games.


He was a sixth-round pick, No. 186 overall, out of Auburn in April, per Giants.com. In three games with one start, he has eight tackles, five of them solo, according to his Giants.com player page.


The caveat: three games is a short stretch, and he has yet to record a sack.


Harbaugh still refused to chase a quick fix. "So I never think that you're one step away, one player away," he said before the deadline.


What Comes Next for the Giants After a Quiet Deadline


The Commanders visit MetLife Stadium on Thursday night. "It's what we do this for. We don't do it for the trades," Harbaugh said, per Duggan. "We do it for the games."


Duggan noted that nothing stops the Giants from reopening Taylor talks in the offseason. He did not report that any are planned. Games against the Jaguars, 49ers and Seahawks come later in the schedule.


Our Take: The Giants Tried, and That Matters


I was not upset when the deadline passed. The Giants tried. My frustration on Tuesday was with the Colts, not with New York.


I also gave John Harbaugh my complete and total endorsement to add good football players in exchange for draft picks. That still stands. Duggan's report shows the bar was a difference-maker, not a depth piece.


As I put it Tuesday, JJ McCarthy was their big trade. That deal happened in September, and it reshaped the season.


The thing to watch now is Bobby Jamison-Travis. If he keeps holding up against the run, keeping the picks will look like the right call.


And keep an eye on the offseason. I think Harbaugh may be laying the groundwork for a huge offseason trade.


Want more Giants coverage? Catch up on all of our latest articles here on the site, and follow @BigBlueFilmRoom on X for every Giants update as it breaks.


About Big Blue Film Room: Big Blue Film Room is an independent New York Giants news site delivering daily news, injury updates and game recaps. We credit and link to the original reporting behind every story, and we correct errors promptly under our Editorial Standards. Learn more about who we are and how we report on our About page.


Get Big Blue Film Room Daily

Every Giants story from yesterday in one free email at 7 AM ET.

Comments


Top Stories

bottom of page